'Madden' Review: A Biopic That Fumbles The Ball
Director David O’Russell makes his return with his latest film Madden, a biopic about the iconic and beloved football coach and commentator John Madden that fumbles the ball.
‘Madden’, as the opening titles reveal, tells the mostly true story of Oakland Raiders football coach John Madden (Nicolas Cage) as it chronicles his time as a coach and best friend to team owner Al Davis (Christian Bale), his transition into becoming a network television NFL commentator and of course his collaboration with EA in creating the Madden video game franchise that has become a cultural phenomenon. Rounding out the impressive cast director David O’Russell has assembled is Kathryn Hahn, Sienna Miller, John Mulaney and Shane Gillis.
John Madden was a larger than life figure with a fascinating story ripe for the big screen. However, the success of a film centered around his life and legacy would certainly hinge on who was cast to portray him, Cage being an intriguing, but peculiar choice due in large part to the fact he looks very little like the man. Unfortunately, despite his deeply committed and lively performance, Cage is woefully miscast as the singular football figure. Putting aside his failure to emulate the man’s distinct voice and rhythm, Cage simply isn’t able to capture the essence of Madden, acting his heart out beneath an avalanche of makeup that can’t obscure or distract from the fact he wasn’t the right fit for the part. There are faint glimmers and moments of a portrayal that catches Madden’s spirit in a bottle, but those moments are fleeting at best, like a whisper in the wind. Cage always refuses to phone it in and that continues to be on full display, his admirable passion and commitment keeping the story trucking even if his performance leaves a fair amount to be desired.
However, Bale is having the time of his life as Davis, radiating charm, magnetism and swagger with effortless ease as he devours any scene he populates. By far and away, the highlight of the film is the central friendship and dynamic between him and Cage, the two sharing palpable comedic chemistry and a symbiotic musicality that brings out the best in both of them. The two are able to flesh out the prickly, complicated, but deeply loving friendship between Madden and Davis, their scenes showing shades of a far more emotionally engaging film than the one they’re in. Hahn also fairs well as Virginia Madden, John’s wife, elevating the lackluster and repetitive material she’s given despite her lack of romantic chemistry with Cage.
O’Russell’s direction surprisingly feels a bit more stiff and reserved here, his usual visual energy and dynamic camerawork all but absent as he takes a more wallflower, documentary style approach to the material, a poor choice that results in a film that lacks considerable energy and momentum throughout when it truly could’ve benefited from both. Despite solid production design and a delightfully vintage aesthetic crafted by veteran DP Robert Richardson that perfectly captures the time period, the film overall feels flat and rather lifeless, a detriment that is especially disappointing considering the larger than life figure at its center who was anything but. It also doesn’t help that O’Russell and writer Cambron Clark’s script is very underwhelming, the humor rarely landing and the emotional elements of Madden’s story lacking the emotional heft necessary to pack a punch. In fact, many of the film’s more emotionally charged moments are shortchanged by unnecessary jokes that not only blunt their emotional impact, but simply aren’t funny altogether.
The storytelling here is also quite frustrating as it predominantly breezes by the three chapters of Madden’s career and legacy with such urgency that none of them have time to breathe or develop the way they rightfully should. Shockingly, despite this approach, the pacing of the film is painfully sluggish, glacially moving from one setup to the next as it unfurls Madden’s story. The section in which the film feels most sure of itself is when it focuses on Madden’s transition from coach to commentator. This section of the film feels the most alive, vibrating with the infectious energy and dynamism Madden was known for, not to mention it’s when Cage comes closest to capturing his aura and presence on screen. For a film that’s nearly two hours, it feels as if O’Russell wasn’t sure how to balance these phases of his career, unwilling to fully commit to any of them, resulting in a biopic that never firmly plants its feet on the field or properly fleshes out the majority of its supporting characters. Hahn and Miller, who plays Davis’ wife Carol Davis, are hamstrung by subpar material that wastes their respective talents substantially and leaves them stranded with very little to explore.
Despite a fantastic cast, occasional glimmers of fun and a true story that is brimming with narrative potential, ‘Madden’ is a biopic that chokes on the field, never getting the ball remotely close to the end zone as it fails to do justice to Madden’s remarkable story and legacy. Some may find enjoyment in this direct to streaming fare, but it’s difficult not to imagine what this film could’ve been if it was placed in the hands of a better suited head coach in the locker room.